The magic button is effective integration!!!

0

The Irving Independent school district quite rightly state:

“The key to good classroom management in a one to one school is acknowledging that there is no “magic button” technology solution that will ensure laptops are used appropriately.  Traditional discipline is only one part of the puzzle.  Effective instruction is even more important. 

 

 

Now I have been teaching in one-to-one classrooms for at least 4 years now and proceeding that I had the options of carts containing banks of computers at all my previous schools.  For this reason managing such a classroom was embedded in my initial teaching experiences.  If I think about it I do have some tricks

1) Lesson Structure: My lesson structure is designed for the initial entering of the room and turning on the computers whilst simultaneous engaging with a displayed starter activity.

2) Classroom structure: My classroom is set up so students work in collaborative groups with their computers facing out.

3) Class exploration: I rotate around my class and get my class used to me looking over their shoulder watching and supporting their progression (I am not even sure if this is related to one-to-one laptop use but just best teaching practice).

4) Classroom expectation:  When I say computers down and look to the front I have a clear expectation that this will happen from the start of the year onward.

5) Considered response: If I see the computer being used in an off task manner I will again just quietly point out the issue and expect the student to move back on task and also note the incidence in my grade book.

6) Consistent response: The students also know that a computer related issue will always be jotted down in my grade book and two comments in a trimester will result in one week without computer access in my class and an e-mail home explaining the issue.  Such an issue rarely does occur but it does include the students having to run upstairs to collect printed worksheets or in some case passively supporting another student who does have computer access.

Yet these are just a list of useful points.  If you want more then I really recommend you checking out Dean Groom’s blog post “23 things about classroom laptops” or Tim Bray’s blog post “5 Tips for Classroom Management within 1:1 Environments“.

However, if I had to find the magic button to success it is simply embedding effective laptop use into the student activities.  So sending a clear message that using the laptop provides the student with the tools to be better and that my teacher wants that from me and I should not waste that opportunity.

 

Dyknow Monitor Screen

 

That would have been a great concluding but I feel that I should be prepared to offer full disclosure.  I also use a tool call DyKnow which is a piece of software which allows me to monitor remotely the screens of my students.  Now I mention this only because it might have an impact on the student body’s acceptance of methods.  Yet I now really only turn this on at the start of class out of some strange habit.  I find it more useful, but actually to show the class a students work (although this is more often than not too slow for practicality) or to quickly share a document (this tool us useful).  Yes, occasionally this may reveal a student not on task but wandering around the class appears to be far more effective and I still do not see it as a crucial part of one-to-one classroom management but could see why some people would appreciate the resource.

Trails and tribulations of the flipped classroom

0

The reflection upon where I have got to with my own flipped classroom seems a sensible culmination of my coetail experience.  From my first introducing the idea to my year 12 Physics class the IT integration has developed.  I am now producing more and more considered vodcasts which reflect my own improved understanding of the tools and the student requirements.  Furthermore the increased teaching time has meant the continued integration of further IT tools into the teaching and learning process.  As my students have now got used to the flipped classroom techniques they are in a position to honestly reflect on their experiences to provide a data driven element to the discussion.

Everyone is already connected (and education is playing catch up)

0

Three events occurred over the last week which got me thinking that education is falling actually behind the interconnected curve which is our digital society.

 

1)      My own wife’s thoughts about how our son takes on problems, in her blog post “On tippy toes”.  Here I appreciate the determination to succeed independently shown but I am also reassured by his continued reliance on the people around him.

Getting the cookies

2)      My own year 11 science class just completed an in-class essay where they were required to bring in notes reflecting the unit question – How do we know what is a good fuel?.  Then once they arrive in class they are presented with the specific essay question.  During my wandering around class and looking at the pre-prepared research I found an e-mail from a senior student explaining how to get the best marks in this particular assignment with regards to how it has been previously set.

3)      My reading of George Siemens excellent introduction to the learning theory of connectivism – “Connectivism:  A Learning Theory for a Digital age”.  In this article he states “When knowledge, however, is needed, but not known, the ability to plug into sources to meet the requirements becomes a vital skill. As knowledge continues to grow and evolve, access to what is needed is more important than what the learner currently possesses.”

Each of these examples captures the importance of being connected.  To me these experiences show 1) we are a social being 2) we can be motivated to use society for our benefit 3) this social learning is already being studied (and has been for almost 10 years).

Yet considering these absolutes I don’t feel that the assessment tasks in education presently reflect the ideals of connectivism.  This statement repeated in the Edutopia article – How should we measure student learning?  For example my own tests still take place in test conditions with no communication with anyone else – so not providing the opportunity to use their connectivity to their benefit.  My essays are on topics undoubtedly (although I work hard for this not to be the case) done by someone before and here I take a, hear no evil and see no evil attitude and provide marks oblivious of the increased benefits of connectivity each cohort of students has.  The for classic science laboratory reports the previous problem is undoubtedly amplified even further.

So now I need to develop assessment which both acknowledges and encourages connectivity.  Yet here I am constrained by an assessment rubric which does not provide the opportunity for a truly challenging open book test.  I believe project based assessment tasks provide better opportunities which I will try to develop.  In fact I would like to integrate such ideals into the energy transfer unit which I am presently revising.

So in conclusion I return to a quote from George Siemens’ article – “The field of education has been slow to recognize both the impact of new learning tools and the environmental changes in what it means to learn. Connectivism provides insight into learning skills and tasks needed for learners to flourish in a digital era.”

Evaluating and integrating technology

0

The classes I would quite happily allow someone into to evaluate the technology integration in my classroom are those that I have had a key role in designing the related unit.  In these my classroom displays effective technology integration due to the fact the technology is seamlessly embedded in my expectations of the actions and outcomes of the students and me.  For example my “flipped” year 12 physics class which both provides the students with a new approach to their own learning and also allowed for the further use range of online simulations and mastery questioning.

There are also lessons, sometimes in units I have designed and sometimes not,   where I am taking a risk and trying out something new.  I recognise that it is not yet happily embedded but I am being informed by the experience which makes it invaluable for future technology integration

However, there are also lessons where prefer that no administrator is going to visit whilst brandishing Lisa Nielsen’s (The Innovative Educator) interesting technology integration classroom visit rubric.  These lessons are more often than not units which I did not have a role in developing.  Yet as they do comprehensively teach the required scientific content I do not feel the right to criticize.

I have been thinking about the best way to encourage technology integration throughout the department I am a member off.  Here I feel that the way forward is by modelling best practice.  This means by placing it at the core of my own unit planning and therefore exposing others.  Yet for this to be successful I cannot just drop it into the unit planner and expect people to follow I know that I will also have to support those how find technology challenging and accept that it is not always for everyone and offer other pathways if necessary.

With all this in mind I am about to start creating a new energy transfer unit for year 11.  My present idea is centred on a project based unit where students create and analyse the energy transfers within their own Rube-Goldberg Machine.

How to tee up a golf ball without bending over

Now what is interesting here, and I recognise in myself, is that I have become very lost in a quite a non-technology focused idea here.  So I intend to ask my school’s own technology support team in on this planning to provide their own perspective and help me see beyond my out of character blinkers.  So I will keep you informed on how this all progresses as we move forward.

Improving my vodcasts?

0

 

Science teacher goes wrong

For those that follow my blog over this past academic year I have been flipping my IB diploma Physics class.  In a previous blog (I Launch myself onto You tube) I shared my initial vodcasts and the related reflection.  So now a few months further down the line I am returning to further reflect on the vodcasts that I produce.  I have happily continued to use the Camtasia software for recording and editing as I find it easy to use and crucially upload with.

The first improvement was quite straight forward.  MOVEMBER was over so I could thankfully remove that ridiculous moustache.  This took an even greater importance when I recognised the unnerving similarities between myself and the lead character of the excellent series Breaking Bad which unfortunately depicts a science teacher loosing their way.

 

The second issue I highlighted was my own hand writing.  For this I did what I often do in the classroom used type text in some for of presentation software such as PowerPoint.  I had been looking at other vodcasts on the net and was aware that some students had commented negatively about vodcasts which spent an excessive amount of time watching the presenter write things out.  Yet had also seen examples where the teachers then rushed through content. With this in mind here is one the vodcasts I produced using these tools considering practical methods to deduce a specific heat capacity.

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZLkggrTGsg&context=C3d40546ADOEgsToPDskKrcGMZV9rSWgtTUOUQKRCi[/youtube]

I selected this vodcast as it highlights two reflections of my own.  Firstly I recognise that at the end as I am going through some calculation examples my explanation kind of tails off.  I really should add some statements like “now consider this question….. and now pause and do you own calculations before the answer appears”.  Secondly my discussion about practical Physics is not very practical – it is a PowerPoint and a floating head.  To capture this aspect I will need to more carefully consider where I set up my webcam or bring someone else into support my filming.  An example of the integration of techniques I am therefore considering is shown here with a vodcast by noted practitioners of the flipped classroom technique Aaron Sams and Jonathan Bergmanns who are discussing a similar topic.

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GubjiyM81S8&feature=relmfu[/youtube]

With respect to my own class progression my first semester has been completed and the average class results are higher then in previous years as are those of the best students but this is a small and talented cohort some I don’t want to over analyse those facts.  For now my flipped classroom journey goes on.

Comparing a year group's MYP Science results responsibly

0

People fear close analysis of their student’s results because of concerns of what it could reveal about them as teachers.  This fear can stop analysis which could provide a fascinating insight into student learning.   For this reason it is great that one group of teachers have allowed me to analyse the results of common assessment tasks for a whole year group across a whole year of learning using IBO MYP Science. The questions I intend to provide data driven answers are:

1)      Is one type of science more difficult to succeed in than another?

2)      Are all assessment tasks of a certain criteria of equal difficulty?

3)      In middle years general science classes does a higher level specialist get better results?

I ask the first question because in theory the criteria referenced system used by the MYP for science is for five of the six criteria used related only to general science skills.  So only has one of six criteria, Criteria C – Knowledge and understanding, would provide an opportunity for any divergence.   An appreciation of this could help teachers provide alternative or extended teaching to reach certain aspects of understanding and re-address any imbalance.

The answer to the second question should help teachers identify which assessment tasks need to be reviewed to improve alignment.

I ask the final question because I want some data driven evidence, and not the reactionary gut instinct that too often drives change, as to if having specialist teaching their own units only is beneficial or if the rewards of a skills based generalist are greater.

 

Is one type of science more difficult to succeed in than another?

Hypothesis: Physics is the most difficult followed by Chemistry and then Biology based on numbers of students who select these units for Diploma studies.

Method: Compare the overall average level for all assessments with those gained just in each science

Results:

Sample Average Level
All 4.29
Biology 4.29
Chemistry 4.17
Physics 4.39

Analysis:

Standard deviation = (Max – Min/ Number of samples)

For all assessment tasks this value is ±0.07

Conclusion:

So subject areas from easiest to mist difficult are Physics, Biology and finally Chemistry.  These results stand surprisingly against popular belief and against the numbers reflected in IB Diploma selection.  Both Physics and Biology stand outside the standard deviation of the average indicating changes need to be made.

Response

Evaluation of the assessment tasks is obviously ongoing but it should be noted the assessment task with the lowest average value was related to biology and has already been dramatically modified to reflect the teacher’s opinions.  This should bring up both the biology average and the overall average up.   There is also continued work in developing the chemistry assessment requirements.

 

Are all assessment tasks of a certain criteria but in different units of equal difficulty?

Hypothesis: The collective teaching experience would identify assessment tasks which where inconsistent with the criteria requirements causing students to under or over perform in excess of one level.

Method: Compare the overall average level for all pupils of each criterion (and within that each subject) to ensure that all the assessment tasks lie within one level.

Results:

Criteria Overall Average Max Min Biology Chemistry Physics
A 4.08 4.29 3.87 4.17 3.86 4.11
B 4.19 4.56 3.47 4.31 3.88 4.64
C 3.95 4.21 3.55 3.55 4.13 3.86
D 4.04 4.22 3.88 3.93 3.88 4.17
E 3.85 4.22 3.22 3.59 3.86 4.11
F 5.40 5.69 5.13 5.61 5.30 5.29

Analysis:

The maximum and minimum levels all lie within 0.5 of a level of the criteria average.

Conclusion:

The agreement between assessment tasks within each criterion is within an acceptable range.

 

In middle years general science classes does a higher level specialist get better results? 

Hypothesis: Criteria referenced method of assessment is transparent and skills based and therefore results will not be aligned with a teachers specialist area.

Method: Compare the change between the overall average of students for each teacher across all criterion and those of each science topic taught.

Results:

Specialist Overall Average Stan. Deviation Biology Units Chemistry Units Physics Units Average Change
Average Change Average Change Average Change
Biology 4.33 0.07 4.40 +0.07 4.17 -0.23 4.28 -0.05 -0.07
Chemistry 3.94 0.15 3.90 -0.04 3.73 -0.17 4.28 +0.36 +0.15
Physics 4.42 0.08 4.40 +0.02 4.33 -0.09 4.53 +0.11 0.04

 

Analysis: The only specialist that improved beyond their overall class averages standard deviation was the Physics specialist yet this was not the largest change for that subject further indicating a lack of alignment between specialist and class performance.  The greatest change occurred in the chemistry units which had already been identified as the most difficult to succeed in – so this further confirms that point.

Conclusion:

As predicted in the hypothesis the criteria referenced assessment system means that a specialist teacher is not shown to have a significant impact on the performance of students in that class.  Considering the spoken opinions of less able students against Physics it is interesting that the class with the lowest initial average had the greatest boost whilst studying that subject.

 

 

 

Additional Notes:

  • The six units studied in the year which can basically be identified as two of each science; chemistry, biology and physics.  And by pairing these up ensure that all assessment tasks are reflected for each subject (considering per unit does not allow this comparison)
  • Each of the 3 teachers had a defined specialism and this was reflected in the units they organised
  • The units were not all taught in parallel so randomizing, and so eliminating, the effect of students learning from their experiences and so improving throughout the year
  • As this sample is taken from a further through the International Baccalaureate Middle Years Programme it is hoped that the core skills will already have been developed

101 Reasons Why Not To See A Band That Has Reformed In 2011

0

101 Reasons why not to see Simply Red

Five years ago in protest directed at people from my school going to see the band Simply Red I constructed 101 reasons from the last year to motivate people to continue their search for new music.  Due to a set of anally retentive personality traits which I am not always proud of I have constructed such a list for each year since.

2011 was on interesting year as although I had no problem identifying 101 tracks indicating there was plenty of great music there was no one really important album which stood out which I could easily have taken three or four tracks from. This is confirmed by looking around and seeing the range of albums selected by critics.  I too do not have a favourite album of the year but there are several which kept on finding their way onto my headphones or classroom speakers.

Zonoscope by Cutcopy.  Just a wonderfully fun dance album that feels refreshingly alive.  Here is a link to the Need You Now video

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r2xovJyBo-0[/youtube]

Kaputt by Destroyer.  A journey back into the 80s returns with only the darkest parts and this then gets put together in such an extraordinary way that it justifies itself as a guilty pleasure of mine and the video for the song Kaputt reflects this guilt so well

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=puu3IvKnSb4[/youtube]

Go Tell Fire To The Mountain by Wu Lyf.  They are not quite there yet but the sound has the potential to fulfill all that is great about British independent music.  Here they are Spitting Blood.

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDTEhWO2wyo&feature=related[/youtube]

Kiss Each Other Clean by Iron & Wine.  Considering the previous more somber albums this was a very pleasant surprise.  Where did the funk come from?  Here is a live track Walking Far From Home (Not on my list but still nice)

Boots Met My Face – Admiral Fallow.  This band rises from the ashes of the Delgardoes with more tune full stories.  Here is a live performance of Taste The Coast.

Then there was the sound track to my west coast of America road trip.  From LA to Bellingham the Fleet Foxes and the Decemberists played as the giant trees and big waves passed by. I also caught Bill Callahan live which was where his album Apocalypse was allowed to reach even greater heights than achieved on the record.

Name                                                                    Artist                                     Album

Dead Against Smoking                                        Admiral Fallow                  Boots Met My Face

Taste The Coast                                                   Admiral Fallow                  Boots Met My Face

Desire                                                                   Anna Calvi                           Anna Calvi

Blackout                                                               Anna Calvi                           Anna Calvi

Every Night My Teeth Are Falling Out                   The Antlers                         Burst Apart

Lose It                                                                   Austra                                   Feel It Break

212                                                                        Azealia Banks

Ice Cream (ft. Matias Aguayo)                               Battles                                  Gloss Drop

Drover                                                                  Bill Callahan                        Apocalypse

Riding for the Feeling                                           Bill Callahan                        Apocalypse

Crystalline                                                           Bjork                                     Biophilia

Lonely Boy                                                          The Black Keys                  El Camino

Sister                                                                     The Black Keys                  El Camino

Shuffle                                                                 Bombay Bicycle Club       A Different Kind Of Fix

Perth                                                                     Bon Iver                               Bon Iver

Till the World Ends (Remix)                                Britney Spears                      Femme Fatale

(feat.Kesha & Nicki Minaj)

Street Halo                                                         Burial                                     Street Halo

County Line                                                        Cass McCombs                  Wit’s End

Blind Faith                                                           Chase And Status             No More Idols

Coastin                                                                 Cities Aviv

There’s Nothing In The Water We Can’t Fight     Cloud Control    Bliss Release

The Great Pan is Dead                                   Cold Cave

Need You Now                                                 Cut Copy                              Zonoscope

Pharaohs & Pyramids                                     Cut Copy                              Zonoscope

Muscle Memory                                               Dananananaykroyd         There Is a way

You Don’t Know                           Danny & The Champions Of The World       Hearts & Arrows

Thrones                                                               The Dears                            Degeneration Street

Calamity Song                                                    The Decemberists           The King Is Dead

Down By The Water                                        The Decemberists           The King Is Dead

Kaputt                                                                  Destroyer                            Kaputt

Chinatown                                                          Destroyer                            Kaputt

Used To Be A Cop                                            Drive-By Truckers            Go-Go Boots

Book Of Revelation                                         The Drums                          Portamento

Wrong Feels Right                                           Dum Dum Girls                  Only in dreams

The A Team                                                        Ed Sheeran                         +

My Mistakes                                                      Eleanor Friedberger        Last Summer

California                                                           EMA                               Past Life Martyed Saints

Changed The Way You Kiss Me                          Example                          Playing In The Shadows

Helplessness Blues                                          Fleet Foxes                       Helplessness Blues

Grown Ocean                                                    Fleet Foxes                       Helplessness Blues

Shake It Out                                               Florence And The Machine          Ceremonials

Pumped Up Kicks                                             Foster The People

novacane                                                            Frank Ocean                       Nostalgia, ultra

Chimes                                                                 Friendly Fires                     Pala

Queen Of Hearts                                                  Fucked Up                          David Comes To Life

Glass Jar                                                               Gang Gang Dance            Eye Contact

Cash And Carry Me Home                                 Ghostpoet                          Peanut Butter Blues & Melancholy Jam

Liiines                                                           Ghostpoet                          Peanut Butter Blues & Melancholy Jam

Die                                                                 Girls                                       Father, Son, Holy Ghost

Sensations In The Dark                                  Gruff Rhys                          Shampoo Hotel

My House                                                           Hercules & Love Affair   Blue Songs

Behold The Hurricane                                    The Horrible Crowes       Elsie

Still Life                                                                 The Horrors                        Skying

Meltdown                                                           Ill Blu                                     Meltdown EP

Me And Lazaru                                                  Iron & Wine                        Kiss Each Other Clean

Tree By The River                                             Iron & Wine                        Kiss Each Other Clean

Another Girl                                                       Jacques Greene

Limit To Your Love                                           James Blake                       James Blake

Lady Luck                                                             Jamie Woon                       Mirrorwriting

I’ll Take Care Of You                                        Jamie xx & Gil Scott-Heron          We’re New Here

Otis                                                                  Jay-Z & Kanye West        Watch the Throne

Cradle                                                             The Joy Formidable         The Big Roar

Banana Ripple                                                   Junior Boys

Civilization                                                       Justice                                  Audio, Video, Disco

Days Are Forgotten                                         Kasabian                              Velociraptor!

Broken Record                                                  Katy B                                   On A MIssion

Bats In The Attic                                               King Creosote & Jon Hopkins      Diamond Mine

Jesus Fever                                                        Kurt Vile                               Smoke Ring For My Halo

Video Games                                                     Lana Del Rey

The Beast                                                            Laura Marling                     A Creature I Don’t Know

Ritual Union                                                       Little Dragon                      Ritual Union

Generation                                                         Liturgy                                  Aesthetica

Try To Sleep                                                       Low                                        C’mon

Midnight City                                                     M83                                       Hurry Up, We’re Dreaming

Bataille                                                              The Men

The Look                                                           M etronomy                       The English Riviera

Polish Girl                                                        Neon Indian

Waiting for My Chance to Come                       Noah and the Whale      Last Night on Earth

The Glorious Land                                            PJ Harvey                            Let England Shake

The Words That Maketh Murder                         PJ Harvey                            Let England Shake

Lotus Flower                                                      Radiohead                          The King Of Limbs

It’s Real                                                              Real Estate                          Days

Wildfire                                                              SBTRKT

Pencil Pimp                                                         Sepalcure

Chloe in the Afternoon                                       St. Vincent                          Strange Mercy

Cruel                                                                    t. Vincent                          Strange Mercy

Under Cover Of Darkness                                    The Strokes                        Angles

The Dream                                                          Thee Oh Sees

New Beat                                                            Toro Y Moi

Bizness                                                                 tUnE-yArDs                        w h o k i l l

If You Wanna                                                     The Vaccines                      What Did You Expect From the Vaccines

Eyes Be Closed                                                  Washed Out                       Within and Without

House Of Balloons – Glass Table Girls       The Weeknd                      House Of Balloons

Holy Ghost                                                          White Lies                           Ritual

Bed Of Nails                                                       Wild Beasts                         Smother

Romance                                                             Wild Flag                              Wild Flag

We Bros                                                               Wu Lyf                                 Go Tell Fire To The Mountain

Spitting Blood                                                    Wu Lyf                                 Go Tell Fire To The Mountain

Civilian                                                                  Wye Oak

Get Away                                                            Yuck                                       Yuck

Although there are quite a few electronic/ dance tracks on the list this is actually the area where I have been most disappointed.  People have spoken about dub-step coming to the fore encompassing other sounds but to me it too often is starting to sound like something I have heard before.   However the world of electronic music did provide me with something I had never seen before and so Big Bad Wolf by Duck Sauce became my music video of the year.

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XKMoVAObbhE&ob=av2e&oref=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fresults%3Fsearch_query%3Dduck%2Bsauce%2Bbig%2Bbad%2Bwolf%26oq%3Dduck%2Bsauce%2Bbig%2Bbad%2Bwolf%26aq%3Df%26aqi%3Dg4%26aql%3D%26gs_sm%3De%26gs_upl%3D7065l2[/youtube]

 

What is carved in stone in our educational standards?

0

I am asking the question when considering several sets of educational standards what is really carved in stone?  For this I have considered:

Stone Carving Some rights reserved by dileeshus

 

1) The International Society for Technology in Education (ISTE) has created a set of standards which they feel reflect the core requirements of students in our digital age.

2) The International Baccalaureate Organisation (IBO) have identified a set of approaches to learning (ATL) skills which should be as standard developed by students from 11 to 16 years old within the Middle Year’s Programme (MYP)

3) The American Association of School Librairians have also created their own set of educational standards.

 

 

 

All of these standards represent what the best and the brightest of these respected organisations feel students today need to develop above and beyond the curriculum content.  For the most part there is a general consensus on these attributes, but there are also some gaps.  Within this blog post I will compare ISTEs NETs with the MYPs ATL skills.

ATLvs ISTE Standards

The table clearly shows the large amount of crossover between the two sets of standards.  The most obvious gap is Digital Citizenship.  This standard reflects the need for students to be a responsible member of a digital society.  However, although not shown as an ATL skill this message is already expressed in the other aeras of interaction of which ATL skills presently only represents a portion of.  Suffice to say this is less of a gap but more of a unjust comparison on my behalf.

What the IBO ATL skills have which the ISTE standards do not is a requirement of self-reflection.  In fact the AASL stands also represent this through their self-assessment strategies.  I think this omission is a failing of those standards.  I believe that our digital times with blogging, tweeting and open-source ideas self reflection is an inherent and vital component.  Also with the high paced changes within the digital landscape to be able to self-reflect and say that I don’t know how to use that tool, because I have never needed to before, but I know a number of resources (often digital) with which can soon learn, would be welcoming.

The two standards which I found most difficult to match related to a final product:

1) create original works as a means of personal or group expression

2) process data and report results

I can understand why a list which pertains to approaches to learning does not strongly focus on the final product.  I finally found the link hidden within a transfer expectation ” making connections—including using knowledge, understanding and skills across subjects to create products or solutions, applying skills and knowledge in unfamiliar situations”.  This is interesting for two reasons.  Firstly I like the fact that the creativity of the ISTE does quite accurately reflect the transfer skills of the IBO – this is a good thing.  I think this highlights a gap in the IBOs ATLs skill which reflects the requirement of an individual to have the motivation to complete a product and also the fact that we all only learn by producing something and reflecting on that and making it better.  So I would like to add two further transfer expectations:

1) self-motivating – to complete a product highlights the transfer of knowledge and understanding

2) personal transfer – to transfer prior experiences to improve future products

 

I launch myself onto Youtube

0

Having spent some time setting up the structure of my reverse learning classroom I have now truly flipped it by making my own knowledge front loading videos.  The final push was that I could not find anything on the web that was just right for my class to cover the concepts of power and efficiency.

I used camtasia recorder to simultaneously capture my screen (writing onto a Smart Note) and my webcam (so adding my face to the proceedings).  It took me a little time to get the section of the screen I wanted to capture correct and I also had to place a pile of books behind my screen to keep it still whilst I was recording.  Yet these were minor teething issues.

For the structure of the vodcast I wanted to keep it short and too the point with; key formula, discussion and then example (s).  I mapped out what I wanted to point out on paper and placed the discussion point and example question at the top of different SmartNote pages.  Structured so I could go over all in one take requiring no time consuming editing – which I managed.

Camtasia recorder automatically transferred the recorded content into a camtasia editing suite in which I added a title screen and then uploaded directly onto my youtube channel. This was incredibly easy!

So here is my first video discussing power:

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EFhedcT3NeY[/youtube]

Here is my second video discussing efficiency:

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xPeX7sIkOMM&feature=mfu_in_order&list=UL[/youtube]

I look back on them and already have some issues.

1) My handwriting is not great and this is accentuated by writing onto the tablet screen.

2) Why did my first video have to be at the end of MOVEMBER.  I have been developing the kind of moustache which should not be seen around young children.

3) It should be displacement not distance in my deconstruction of the power formula.

Yet although I have those minor concerns I am really pleased because with the outcome because of the relative ease and the short time they can be produced in.  These are the features which I need to convince me to keep on producing these vodcasts.  Plus I know next time I teach this content I will do it again and it will be better (just like all teaching should be).

PowerPoint in my classroom

0

So it needs to be made clear from the start the context in which I am discussing the use of PowerPoint.  I am a teacher and I am talking about the use of PowerPoint by a secondary school teacher during a class.

1)    This means I am not talking about the corporate presentation which is mentioned in Seth Godin’s blog on the Really Bad PowerPoint  (but I have responded to some of his advice from the point of view of a teacher at the end of this blog).

2)    I am also not talking about getting students to use PowerPoint in my class to make presentations as pertinently denigrated by Edward Tufte in “PowerPoint is Evil” .

 

My context is as a tool which I regularly use in my classroom to help provide structure for my teaching and to both stimulate and support my students’ learning.

1)    Easy use

No one has ever told me that PowerPoint was anything but easy to use.  Plus it is most effective when kept simple.

2)    Planning

I use it as a visual template for my lesson which helps me consider the various stages of my lesson and the time required.  Plus it forces me to identify any additional resources – mine is a science class so this is vital.

Lesson starting slide by Neil Commons

3)    Setting the stage for the lesson

I like my students to enter my classroom, and at least initially, be presented with familiarity to help them settle and organise themselves.  PowerPoint provides me with a clear template to the start of each lesson with a title, objective and often key words.  For me having this pre-built means that my class to class transition is faster so that I can greet my students as they enter.  For my students it provides a familiar structure and a clear guide as to how to organise their work in OneNote page (we are a one-to-one laptop school).

4)    Starting activity

A starting activity is something that will stimulate an inclusive response and it is often an image, in recognition of the visual literacy of my students, and these can be very easily pasted into or developed within PowerPoint.

5)    Zoning in (the teaching bit)

I will take 10 minutes to help students zone in on an idea.  PowerPoint allows me to integrate diagrams and animations into these explanations which assist the visual learners in the class.

6)    Activity instructions

Having the instructions clearly displayed on a PowerPoint stage means there is a constant point of reference available to all the students, it is especially useful for my more active students who get involved but then forget what exactly they should be doing.   This will also include extension tasks for my gifted students.

7)    Personal Reflection

My lesson is not static for the existence of a PowerPoint. I will nearly always be making live adaptions in response to the class and as I have a saved version this acts as an ever improving starting template for the next time I teach similar content.

8)    Tailoring for the individuals

Yes I do worry about the font, font size and font colour because I need to take into consideration the short-sighted, colour blind student with reading disabilities in my class.  However, I do agree with what Don McMillan says in his sketch “Life After Death by PowerPoint”

9)    Spider writing

My board writing skills look like that of an elementary student at the best of times so having content typed out really helps me.

 

So those are the reasons why I continue to use PowerPoint in my classroom.  Is there another tool which helps me do all these things with such ease?

 

*Seth does propose 4 steps to help improve a corporate business PowerPoint, which I have paraphrased, compressed down and responded to:

1)    Use cue cards

No – I am a teacher and I really know my stuff

2)    Make slides that reinforce your words, not repeat them

Yes – good point and I continue to strive to do that

3)    Create a supporting written document

Yes – when I am using a PowerPoint I do not expect my class to be constantly taking notes. I will create notes for later reference or integrate key points into other learning instructions

4)    Create a feedback cycle

I am constantly setting formative assessment tasks, whether it’s a well-considered question or an engaging activity, which allow me to evaluate an individual student’s understanding. I also expect my students to say, “Hey Mr. Neil. I just don’t get it. Can we go over it again?”

 

Go to Top